CBS Sports: Community. In this post Burkholder examines the risks and rewards of the Saturday Night Fights presented by CBS and ProElite, Inc. and he discusses the factors that could be modified to appeal to more viewers. The second post I came across, "Silva asserts himself atop Sherdog pound-for-pound rankings", is published by ESPN: Mixed Martial Arts in association with Sherdog. The post ranks the ten best pound-for-pound fighters in the world with facts and opinions defending the given rank of each of the ten fighters. For your convenience I have left my comments on the two posts below, but they also can be found directly on the author's blogs."The risks and rewards of "Saturday Night Fights'"
Comment:
To begin, I would like to thank you for your well written and insightful arguments discussing the importance of a successful event on May 31st. I could not agree more with your ideas concerning the magnitude of the event and have expressed many similar ideas in my previous posts. As you said, "if EliteXC makes a lackluster showing before a bunch of first-time viewers, they could turn those people off to ever watching MMA again" therefore, I believe we will be able to determine the success of the event based on the ratings of the next three events. The first event may not receive the sought after ratings but, if the following three events have higher ratings than the first, we will know that a positive message was delivered to the viewers and that the message was spread to those that were not able to see the first event by those that viewed. This idea can work both ways. If the first event has the highest ratings we can assume that the viewers did not respond well to the fights and/or the dancers, DJ, and commentators as you mentioned and elected to pass on the opportunity to watch the next three events. You also stated that the success of the event will be evident in the recognition of EliteXC fighters, an increase in ad sales, the fighters' incomes, and the willingness of fighters to leave the UFC and join EliteXC. I completely agree with all of these arguments. If the first event is considered a success, the fighters that competed in the event will receive instant recognition from the new mixed martial arts fans because they could very well be the only fighters those fans have seen in competition. Due to that recognition many fighters in the UFC may be more willing to leave the organization, if they will be paid a similar salary, in search of national exposure, thus forcing the UFC to raise the salaries of its fighters to prevent them from venturing off to EliteXC. Also, with high ratings we could see many companies invest in EliteXC in order to have their services and products advertised in remaining three events.
"Silva asserts himself atop Sherdog pound-for-pound rankings"
Comment:
First I would like to thank you for your well researched and informative opinions on the top pound-for-pound fighters in the world. It is evident in your work that a lot of time and effort were put in to the development of this list that serves as a useful source for mixed martial arts fans and bloggers. I agree with a majority of the list and appreciate your ability to refrain from a bias in favor of any one mixed martial arts company when ranking the fighters, but I do have a few concerns. The main concern is the placement of Fedor Emelianenko (pictured above) as the third best pound-for-pound fighter in the world. I agree that he possesses fighting abilities that can be considered second to none and that with two decisive victories over Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira he has earned
a position on this list, but if you chose to exclude Randy Couture from this list for not fighting you must give Emelianenko a lower ranking for not fighting qualified fighters. If you look at Emelianenko's previous two fights you will see victories over Matt Lindland, who has competed as a middleweight or light heavyweight for a large part of his career, and the inexperienced Hong-Man Choi that took place seven long month apart. Meanwhile, Randy couture has only been retired for several months and has posted wins over former UFC heavyweight champion Tim Sylvia and the very explosive and dangerous Gabriel Gonzaga. Therefore, because of the size and talent level of Emelianenko's last two opponents and the fact that Couture was emitted from the rankings, I would have ranked Emelianenko no higher than fourth on the list and given Georges St. Pierre (picture on the left) the third spot having defeated Josh Koscheck and the greatest welterweight of all time Matt Hughes in his last two bouts. That being said, I would like to know where you would place Georges St. Pierre on this list if he is able to avenge his loss to Matt Serra on April 19th. If he can dominate the fight, as he did in the third Matt Hughes fight, and leave no doubt in the minds of the viewers that he is the number one welterweight in the world, I believe he deserves at least the second spot on the list, making a possible, but unlikely, match up with the best middleweight and pound-for-pound fighter in the world, Anderson Silva, even more appealing.








